Jeff Michalic

Jeff is an experienced land broker who specializes in various types of properties such as investment, tillable, recreational, and hunting lands. With over 27 years of marriage, he and his wife Buffy are proud parents to three children: Madison, Hunter, and Ben. Having grown up in western Indiana, Jeff has a deep understanding of people's connection to land and their love for the outdoors. When he's not busy helping clients buy or sell properties, Jeff enjoys engaging in outdoor activities like bow hunting for whitetail deer and turkeys, fishing, land management, and coaching.

Jeff's true passion lies in managing properties to grow and hunt mature trophy whitetails. He combines this passion with his extensive knowledge of real estate to become the go-to guy for buying or selling land in his area. Jeff's exceptional skills in the field have earned him four-time Pinnacle Club awards for sales in the nation, having sold over 25,000 acres from 2018 to 2022. You can easily get in touch with Jeff through his cell phone at 812-230-4503 , office at 765-505-4155 , or email at jeffm@mossyoakproperties.com.

View My Listings

Testimonials

Owner
I would like to thank Jeff Michalic for his professional expertise and tenacity in handling the sale of our family farm in Indiana. I am also a real estate broker (in Montana), and this sale was one of the most difficult transactions I have ever been involved in. It required two surveys and an attorney to consummate the sale. Jeff stayed on top of every step and reported every progress or setback as each occurred. I highly recommend Jeff to represent you in the sale or purchase of your property.
Jolynne Vermillion County
Seller
Our mother, who passed had farmland in Vigo County, Indiana since the 1950s. We decided to put the land up for sale (188 acres). We searched for realtors and were very happy to come across Jeff Michalic. From our first conversation, Jeff was professional, knowledgeable, honest, and personable. And in spite of the land sitting idle for a few years with no crops and having limited access, Jeff managed to find perspective clients. He even recommended a local farmer, which we hired to clear the land and plant crops. After about a year of not much interest, Jeff was open to discussing a new strategy and made suggestions on how to lower the price and entice a variety of potential buyers. It included considering wetland programs, and leasing part of the land for hunting and fishing. This strategy worked, and we recently negotiated a cash offer with a buyer. For these reasons, I highly recommend Jeff as a realtor who specializes in farmland on the IL and IN sides.
Samone A. Vigo County Indiana

Land for Sale by Jeff Michalic

Under Contract
Clay County, IN
Gorgeous A-Frame Home with Spectacular Lake Views Welcome to 4885 S Whippoorwill Lake Drive, an enchanting A-frame home nestled just north and east of the charming town of Clay City, Indiana. This picturesque property boasts 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths,...
32.2± Acres
|
$395,000
New Listing
Clark County, IL
Charming Rural Retreat with Acreage in Dennison, IllinoisAddress: 20017 N Dunlap Road, Dennison, ILPrice: Upon RequestWelcome to 20017 N Dunlap Road, a rural haven situated just 1.5 miles West of the Indiana state line, near Dennison, Illinois. This ...
14.02± Acres
|
$300,000
New Listing
Vermillion County, IN
Welcome to your opportunity to transform this rustic gem into your dream home! Nestled on a spacious 1.25-acre lot in the picturesque town of Cayuga, Indiana, this fixer-upper boasts immense potential and endless possibilities.Key Features: 3 Bedroom...
1.25± Acres
|
$39,900
New Listing
Clay County, IN
Bowling Green 123: The Ultimate Hunter's Paradise Are you ready to embrace the call of the wild? Look no further than the magnificent Bowling Green 123 - 123 acres of rugged, untamed beauty nestled in the heart of eastern Clay County, Indiana, just ...
123± Acres
|
$652,269
Under Contract
Shelby County, IL
The Shelby County  40: A Rural Paradise Awaits Discover your very own slice of country heaven with the Shelbyville 40, a pristine 40-acre parcel nestled just south of charming Shelbyville, Illinois. This property offers a remarkable blend o...
40± Acres
|
$315,000
New Listing
Vermillion County, IN
Welcome to 1230 W 3rd Street, Clinton, IN 47842, a recently remodeled 5-bedroom, 2-bathroom home that seamlessly blends modern upgrades with the charm of rural living. Situated on 5.75 acres of land, this property offers both tranquility and convenie...
5.75± Acres
|
$395,000
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
Introducing the Fayette 105 – a captivating property nestled in the scenic Northern Vigo County, offering an oasis for nature enthusiasts and those seeking a serene retreat. This unique estate presents a diverse landscape, catering to various w...
105± Acres
|
$577,500
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
Presenting the Fayette 96: A hidden treasure in Northern Vigo County. Spanning across acres of captivating terrain, this property seamlessly blends untamed wilderness with curated open spaces, making it a haven for nature enthusiasts and outdoor afic...
96± Acres
|
$528,000
New Listing
Vigo County, IN
Presenting the Fayette 37 – a property located in Northern Vigo County, rich in natural features. This land offers a mix of open pasture and new growth across half of its area, providing a favorable environment for quail, pheasants, and whiteta...
37.77± Acres
|
$225,000
New Listing
Parke County, IN
Welcome to 4964 S. Timberlake Circle, a stunning property nestled in the highly sought-after Parke County, Indiana. This remarkable home offers an abundance of features and a prime location within the prestigious Timberlake gated community. Prepare t...
20± Acres
|
$548,000
New Listing
Clay County, IN
Welcome to your dream property in Indiana! Lot #11 offers a rare opportunity to own a breathtaking 31.24-acre parcel that borders the Chinook fish and wildlife area. This natural wonderland is perfect for those who love the great outdoors!This lot of...
31.24± Acres
|
$249,920
Under Contract
Vermillion County, IN
14314 South County Road 170 West is 9 acres of vacant ground. With city water and power at the paved road, this would be an idea location for that new home or weekend retreat. Just over 1 acre of the this parcel is open pasture or small trees, and th...
9± Acres
|
$76,500
New Listing
Clay County, IN
The Big Slough 43 is located in southwest Clay County and is just one property east of the Vigo County - Clay County line. The property features a shipping container shed that doubles as a bridge during times of high water. A great deal of dirt work ...
43± Acres
|
$245,100
New Listing
Parke County, IN
2093 W. Tickridge Road is a 33 acre residential property located in southwestern Parke County, Indiana. This property features a log home that originated in 1856. It was moved to the property and rebuilt in 1970. In 1982, it underwent a major renovat...
33± Acres
|
$385,000
Under Contract
Sullivan County, IN
Welcome to 1431 E Paxton Depot Street, a charming property nestled in the serene town of Paxton in Sullivan County. This corner lot gem boasts 2140 square feet of living space, offering comfort and style. With 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, this home is...
2.46± Acres
|
$169,900
1

Contact Jeff Michalic